Phosphate mining remains a thorn in the flesh

Fishing companies want to prevent ‘flying ecologically blind’

09 July 2020 | Business

Windhoek • [email protected]


After environment minister Pohamba Shifeta withdrew a clearance certificate for planned phosphate extraction due to pressure by conservationists, the future of the controversial project has now become a legal dispute in the High Court.

An application by the Confederation of Namibian Fisheries Associations was before Judge Harald Geier yesterday to seek a general ban against marine phosphate extraction off the Namibian coast.

At the hearing, the question was raised as to whether a prospecting license received by Namibian Marine Phosphate (NMP) on 26 July 2011 was still valid.

According to the plaintiff, this licence – based on which NMP is seeking approval for the planned phosphate mining – already expired on 5 February 2013 because the respondents had failed to prepare an environmental impact study for the planned phosphate mining within six months.

They say, regardless of the required clearance certificate, NMP has forfeited the authority to mine the mineral, which is mainly used as fertilizer, in an area of around 2 233km² from the sea floor in an area about 60km off the coast, around 120km southwest of Walvis Bay.

Fishing sector protests

The fishing sector opposes the project on the grounds that a suction dredger is used to extract phosphate from a depth of between 180 and 300 meters, and that roughly 5.5 million tons of marine sediment is transported to the surface each year.

During the planned duration of the project, large amounts of sediment would be dredged from the sea floor in an area of around 60km², thereby driving fish out of the area.

The plaintiffs also argue that the release of particulate matter and minerals could have previously unknown consequences for plankton and other organisms in the ocean, which depend on seabed nutrients and serve as food source for fish.

Should these organisms disappear, fish would be deprived of their food source, which could lead to a disturbance of the ecological balance and could trigger a marine chain reaction with unpredictable consequences.

The applicants also claim that the area identified by NMP serves as spawning grounds for many commercial fish species and a drastic decrease in these species could be expected there. This would lead to a loss of biodiversity and a decrease in stocks, resulting in a drastic impact on the Namibian fishing industry, which not only creates thousands of jobs, but also makes a significant contribution to the gross domestic product.

Environmental concerns ‘unfounded’

In reaction, NMP denies that the planned phosphate mining could lead to a “noticeable impairment” in marine ecology, disturbing the natural balance in the ocean, or cause irreparable damage to the fauna occurring there, describing various reports as “rumors, speculations, guesswork and conjecture”.

At the same time, the company emphasizes that it has carried out intensive research and issued various reports that phosphate mining is far less environmentally harmful than marine diamond mining off the coast.

Furthermore, NMP says that the planned extraction area is only 0.0003% of the total territory of Namibia and is not part of a commercially used fishing area. Apart from the fact that the phosphate deposits are “extremely localized”, the extraction would take place at a depth of around 200m, where no fishing is usually done.

NMP also cited a study that only the Atlantic anglefish (1% of the total stock) and hake (0.05% of total stock) could suffer from possible phosphate degradation.

Judge Geier reserved judgment at the end of the hearing on 7 July.

Similar News

 

Nissan Walvisbaai en Swakopmund smelt saam

5 days ago - 31 July 2020 | Business

Swakopmund • [email protected] Pupkewitz Nissan op Walvisbaai is die jongste slagoffer van massa-afdankings en die sluiting van besighede in die tyd van Covid-19.’n Werknemer...

‘Most important uranium discovery since Husab’

1 week ago - 27 July 2020 | Business

Swakopmund • [email protected] “In our view, this is possibly the most important uranium discovery in Namibia since [the company] Extract Resources discovered the occurrence...

Wieland chosen as Dunes Mall’s first influencer

1 week ago - 23 July 2020 | Business

Walvis Bay • [email protected] Namibian beauty queen, luminary and entrepreneur, Andeline Wieland (25), secured an agreement to be Dunes Mall’s first influencer.The Swakopmund-raised Wieland...

First Covid-19 case registered at local mine

2 weeks ago - 21 July 2020 | Business

Swakopmund • [email protected] Swakop Uranium recorded its first positive Covid-19 case, chief operations officer (COO) of the mine Angula Kalili confirmed.According to Kalili,...

Beach Hotel employees fed up

2 weeks ago - 19 July 2020 | Business

Swakopmund • [email protected] Dissatisfied employees complaining of harsh labour treatment from their employers at Beach Hotel Swakopmund, held a demonstration at the premises on...

Innovative businesswomen awarded

3 weeks ago - 13 July 2020 | Business

Walvis Bay •[email protected] Local entrepreneur and food safety consultant Ruth Martinez-Lago was one of 54 ladies from across Africa who emerged as a...

New beginnings for Langer Heinrich

4 weeks ago - 08 July 2020 | Business

Swakopmund • [email protected] “Paladin’s focus is to restart operations at Langer Heinrich uranium mine,” said managing director Ian Purdy. “Our existing infrastructure and ten...

Pick n Pay clears the air

1 month - 02 July 2020 | Business

Walvis Bay Pick n Pay responded to what it terms misleading reports that appeared about the closure of its store in Walvis Bay yesterday.According...

Pick n Pay trims workforce

1 month - 18 June 2020 | Business

Pick n Pay announced today that it will be restructuring its operations in an effort to set the business on a path to sustainability.The 100%...

Coastal traders ask for restrictions to be lifted

1 month - 18 June 2020 | Business

Ogone Tlhage Informal traders at the coast have joined those asking for level-one restrictions to be lifted in the Erongo Region, saying that they have...

Latest News

Celebrating 250 years of Beethoven...

6th of August 14:42 | Art and Entertainment

The German Embassy in Windhoek will present a classical concert by Namibian musicians Galilei Njembo (tenor/baritone), Trudy Gertze (soprano) and Ruzanna Mnatsakanyan (piano)...

Coastal residents demand an end...

6th of August 14:38 | Local News

Walvis Bay • [email protected] Coastal residents once again took their plight to the streets.Residents from Walvis Bay staged a protest against the ongoing lockdown and...

NAMAs go online

19 hours ago | Art and Entertainment

The 10th Namibian Annual Music Awards will kick off soon, but this time live and online!Up for grabs is a total of N$1.2 million that...

Applications now open for grade...

19 hours ago | Education

Walvis Bay The regional directorate of education announced that application forms for pre-primary, grade 1 and grade 8 learners for 2021 will become available...

Police bust cannabis cultivators

19 hours ago | Crime

Walvis Bay Three young men were arrested in Walvis Bay during two separate drug busts for cultivating, harvesting and being in possession of cannabis.A...

Couple nabbed for fraud, money...

1 day - 04 August 2020 | Crime

Walvis Bay •[email protected] A couple from Walvis Bay who allegedly defrauded a Swiss man of more than N$1.1 million made their first...

Mother sacrifices her life in...

1 day - 04 August 2020 | Disasters

Swakopmund Three people lost their lives in a shack fire that broke out in Swakopmund’s DRC informal settlement on Sunday.The regional crime investigations...

Ministry of defence rubbishes bogus...

1 day - 04 August 2020 | Ministries

Audio and video footage that has been circulating on social media claiming that Chinese soldiers have entered into Namibia, are untrue.“There is no iota of...

Sixty-four new cases

1 day - 04 August 2020 | Health

Namibia recorded 64 new Covid-19 cases today. The minister of health and social services Dr Kalumbi Shangula also announced 24 new recoveries. This number also...

Load More