Judge orders mine to make severance payment

Worker fired using derogatory term

19 October 2020 | Crime

Swakopmund • Erwin Leuschner

In his High Court ruling Judge Thomas Masuku came to the conclusion that Swakop Uranium, which operates the Husab uranium mine, will have to pay Cyrill Möller compensation of N$720 000 if he is reinstated. If he does not take up his post again, the company has to pay him N$960 000.

At the centre of the legal dispute are the words “Ching Chong Pang”, which Möller had used in an internal email. In the judgment Masuku stated that Swakop Uranium is a predominantly Chinese company and a subsidiary of China Guandong Nuclear Power Holding Corporation, based in Beijing, China.

On 31 August 2017, Kevin Duan, an employee in Beijing, reportedly sent an email to several staff members - including Möller. The content was in Mandarin. Möller, who held the position of technical coordinator: training, engineering and maintenance, replied: “I am not Chinese. Who are you?”

Duan replied, explaining that the email was sent by accident and that Swakop Uranium employees were not affected. Möller responded with the words “Ching Chong Pang”.

The company described these words as racist and derogatory since some English speakers used this term to mock Chinese people. Disciplinary proceedings were therefore been initiated and although Möller stated that he had not reacted maliciously, he was relieved from duty.

Möller then took his case to the labour court, which ruled in his favour. Accordingly, Swakop Uranium had been ordered to reinstate him and / or to pay the aforementioned severance payment.

Swakop Uranium appealed against this decision in the High Court.

“The only problem that creates a serious issue is the fact that the complainant (Swakop Uranium) did not provide evidence during the disciplinary process that the term used is as alleged to be racist or derogatory to people of Chinese origin,” Masuku said, adding that “apparently some employees felt aggrieved by the words, but no one asked to present such evidence during the disciplinary proceedings.”

The judge therefore came to the same conclusion as the labour court and the disciplinary procedure was incorrect, and thus ruled in Möller’s favour.

Similar News

 

‘Report bridge railing thieves’

1 week ago - 16 June 2021 | Crime

Swakopmund • [email protected] The police have called for help from the public to identify persons who are illegally removing metal rails and uprights holding...

NDF member in the dock for corruption

1 week ago - 15 June 2021 | Crime

Walvis Bay • [email protected] A member of the Namibia Defence Force (NDF) who is being accused of committing fraud, made his first appearance...

Court falls victim to crime

1 week ago - 14 June 2021 | Crime

Swakopmund The Erongo Police Unit Commander for Community Affairs, Inspector Ileni Shapumba, confirmed that another break-in took place at the Swakopmund magistrate’s court on Monday.“Our...

Bail application by suspected serial rapist fails

1 week ago - 14 June 2021 | Crime

Walvis Bay • [email protected] An alleged serial rapist who terrorized women in Kuisebmond late last year will remain in police custody after his...

Police to conduct target practice

1 week ago - 11 June 2021 | Crime

Omaruru • [email protected] The Ministry of Home Affairs, Immigration and Safety announced that it intends to conduct shooting exercises near Omaruru on Saturday and...

Congolese national remains behind bars

1 week ago - 10 June 2021 | Crime

Swakopmund • [email protected] The Congolese national Gilbert Kalenga (31) will remain in custody after he was denied bail. This comes after he was arrested...

Taxi driver wanted

2 weeks ago - 09 June 2021 | Crime

The Kuisebmond Crime Investigation Unit is requesting public assistance in tracing a possible witness. This person, who is a taxi driver, allegedly picked up a...

Congolese national busted with N$1.3 million worth of dagga...

2 weeks ago - 09 June 2021 | Crime

Walvis Bay • [email protected] The Erongo Drug Law Enforcement Sub-division made a major drug bust in Swakopmund on Tuesday, when a Congolese man...

Pensioner killed in Henties attack

2 weeks ago - 08 June 2021 | Crime

The trend of criminals attacking and assaulting elderly persons in Swakopmund seems to have blown over to neighbouring Henties Bay.Police in the Erongo region are...

Two murders in Kuisebmond

2 weeks ago - 06 June 2021 | Crime

Coast A murder case was reported after a police officer (constable) was stabbed to death at about 00h30 in James Brown Street, Kuisebmond on...

Latest News

Calls to rename UNAM Stadium...

3 hours ago | Sports

Windhoek • [email protected] Former UNAM FC head coach Woody Jacobs says it would be fitting for the UNAM Stadium in Pioneers Park in...

Motion tabled to rescind selling...

3 hours ago | Local News

Walvis Bay • [email protected] A motion to rescind a council resolution made in 2014 in terms of Narraville extension 12 and 14 was...

Namport, Meatco sign MOU

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Local News

Walvis Bay The Namibian Ports Authority (Namport) and the Meat Corporation of Namibia (Meatco) recently signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU).The two entities aim...

Seidler wen sy 'doodstryd' na...

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Local News

Tielman van Lill – Phillip Seidler het die eerste Namibiër in die geskiedenis geword wat die Olimpiese Spele in die oopwaterdissipline oor 10 kilometer kwalifiseer.In...

No patient left behind

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Local News

Swakopmund • [email protected] hospitals across the country are overcrowded – a situation that is described as serious. Thankfully, “we have not yet had to turn...

Sop om die koue te...

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Local News

Walvisbaai • [email protected] Alet Smit is hard aan die werk om 'n sopkombuis op Walvisbaai te begin wat spesiaal vir kinders van spesifiek dié...

Pendeldiens maak 'n verskil

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Local News

Walvisbaai • [email protected] Om na die gemeenskap om te sien, lê Carlo van der Merwe nog altyd na aan die hart. Te midde van die...

Tides

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Fishing

Tuesday, 22 June Low 07:22 High 13:46 Low 19:34 High 02:00 Wednesday, 23 June High ...

Grumpy’s Fishing Report

1 day - 22 June 2021 | Fishing

•Grumpy Gramowsky Canopy and Maketu’s were the pick of the week. Wow, so many big galjoen and steenbras were caught and brought to shore,...

Load More